Agatha Christie is famously known as the Queen of Crime, and her mastery of the whodunit genre uses tight pacing, secluded settings, and an ensemble cast where everyone has a motive. Put director Susan Cridland O'toole in charge and it moves up several notches. Expect the Unexpected.
With a stella cast of quality actors who took the audience on a roller coaster game of guess who is telling the truth, we were teased and taunted by the ever-shifting perspective of who really did it.
Damien Campagnolo plays Michael Starkwedder, climbing in a window of a country manor to find a dead man in a wheelchair and a woman seemingly overcome by shock who confesses to the murder. With it being very evident he was shot, gory but not nightmarish luckily. But who is Michael, Damien plays his character as a stranger under the spell of the beautiful murderess - but watch for the subtle clues, he is a master of the poker face.
Viper Valu is dressed to kill and gives the audience the many sides of the newly widowed Laura Warwick, stringing the audience along with a mixed outburst of emotion and displays of a supposedly fragile physique.
All of the cast brought their characters to life and are to be commended on their stage skills. Crisp audible dialogue so the more mature of us didn't miss a word.
The household made up of Frances Price, Al Bromback, Petra Donnison, Andrew Paltridge, all deserve a mention for their characterisations and superb performances. From the energetic unstable Jan, played by Al who brought the childlike characteristics mixed with "Chucky" the killer to life to the more sedate matriarch figure of Mrs. Warwick played by Petra - all made the plot thicken, muddling the evidence until it was not clear who killed Richard Warwick.
Jeremy Wellwood played Inspector Thomas and whether intentional he brought rather a Pink Panther vibe to the role with his expressive eyebrows and facial expressions, giving the inspector a rather comedic persona. Aided by the clumsy Sergeant Cadwallader, played by Tom Cranitch, the audience were not left surprised they couldn't solve the crime as the clever script unraveled the clues.
Julian Farrar, played by Peter Norton, was very adept in playing the caring and then cold lover of (not going to spoil it, you have to see the play).
Set and costumes were excellent and look for a clue - a colour -again the director is making you use your powers of observation.
Nash has a dedicated team of volunteers who spend many hours creating effective sets - in this case it is the study of the victim.
Credits must also go to the production team and front of House, who deserve individual mention for the great effort and such a lovely welcoming theatre group.
Set Construction-Rob Crook (who played the victim very still), Phil Carney, Paul vanLieshout, Eddie Bruce, John stibbard
Lighting Design & Sound- Phil Carney (love the music choices Phil and Susan, very story appropriate)
Programmes- John Stibbard, Poster Design- Jason Nash, Banner-Gillian Nicholas
So, if you think you have read the story, do yourself a favour and see it brought to life.
You will well and truly get to make use of the grey matter.
The Unexpected Guest opened on 13 November and closes on the 5th of December at the New Farm Nash Theatre located in the Merthyr Road Uniting Church. Check out their website www.nashtheatre.com as they have also just released their 2027 season.
Written by Jack Holden, the solo play ‘Cruise’ begins by following Jack, a clueless young gay man who volunteers for a queer helpline and is far out of his depth. He’s incredibly nervous about saying the wrong thing, he thinks his older co-worker is a slight creep, and it becomes increasingly obvious he knows nothing about his queer history. On a disastrous weekend shift, Jack picks up a call from Michael, who after a bit of prodding, retells the adventures he got up to in Soho as the AIDs crisis began.
Leading us through the events is Fraser Morrison, any director’s dream actor. As one would hope in any solo performance, his character work is executed with mechanical precision. Morrison’s voice work, aided by Linda Nicholls-Gidley, is without fault. Each character’s accent was crafted distinctly and has their own rhythm, speed and inflection. Further, Morrison is a beautiful mover. Enriched by movement director Jeremy Lloyd, Morrison’s body somehow manages to contain all the characters in this ever-shifting nightlife. From older and regal singers, to annoying twinks, Morrison shapeshifts before our eyes.
Although the character switching is a feast, my favourite moments were when Morrison was able to sit in the quiet and silent moments of these characters, letting us watch the internal ticking before the clubbing returned. I was especially struck by his performance of Dave, Michael’s boyfriend, and the restraint and gentleness that exuded a presence that was both erotic and warm. Sean Landis’ direction leads with the softness of these gay men, who were/are too tired to be angry or even upset. The grief held by these characters, like Michael and Jack’s co-worker Kevin, is cradled delicately and is never made into a spectacle.
Landis keeps Morrison moving across the exquisite and fragmented set designed by Chelsea Wheatley. The set is broken up into four spaces, the office, bar, studio and raised dance platform. Each is drenched in a signature colour, furthered by Tom Hicks lighting. It reminds me of the bold and block colouring of 80s films and fashion, creating an almost technicolour and campy saturation. Most of the spaces manage to evade concrete definition, being vague enough in purpose to transform into something else; the music studio becomes an underground cinema, a helpline office becomes a home.
The sound design by Wheatley keeps us right in the centre of the clubs and bars while being accurate to the period and carefully manoeuvring us through the story. The composition builds beautifully and is amplified by the in-story creation of music that makes everyone want to join Morrison on the floor (in fact someone a few seats over from me tried to Shazam it). I want to highlight the manipulation of Morrison’s mic and his melting in and out of the music as Michael’s story comes to an end which was necessary in that scene’s ability to bring me to tears.
Though Holden writes beautifully, there are some scenes that feel unnecessary and even detractive as the show goes on. After a major event two thirds through the play, the show begins to lose steam. Slowed down by a conversation with a character we haven’t met, it has to once again build up momentum. The final stretch doesn’t tell me anything I didn’t already know, and distils the tragedy without giving us the time to feel the weight. While this was mainly an issue I had with the script, I do wonder if there was a way to revitalise and reinvent the repetitive staging of the traveling of club to bar to club to bar. The ending also feels like a bit of a fairy-tale wrap up when we come back to Jack, playing out the implications it already meticulously constructed.
‘Cruise’ is not just about the loss of queer history, culture and people that were lost in the AIDs crisis, but the grief of surviving it. The loss was so monumental that it feels difficult to enjoy sticking around. Michael says he now has a simple life and “a handful of friends,” which Jack obliviously calls “a nice life,” illuminating the generational chasm between them. Fruit Box Theatre has done a wonderful job of making me feel this to my core.
‘Cruise’ will most certainly be a show people will continue to talk about and you’ll be annoyed to have missed. I sincerely hope we’ll be blessed by future Fruit Box productions touring down from Sydney to continue to show us the skill of their team.
Suzie is a romantic at heart, believing that somewhere out there waiting for her, is the one. Until recently, she's been content to sleep with dubious men, considering each red flag a case study; typically, Suzie is confident in the role of break-upper, but now finds herself on the receiving end of the old heave-ho, after getting roped in by a rascal who over-promised and under-delivers. In a spiral, she resorts to the unhelpful 'help' of a story narrator, who offers her turn of the 21st century dating advice to win him back, which Suzie comically follows, spurned by both the ex that broke up with her and a Susan Sontag dictum holding that while men mature, women merely fade away.
Reassuringly, there is no fading away throughout Suzie Sex Binge. In the title role she wrote and performs, Madeline Armit's effervescent energy captivates throughout; sweetly naive and upbeat with more than a touch of the 'tism, she is not even momentarily the invisible woman her character fears becoming, as she approaches her 30th birthday unmarried. Rather, she bungles her way brightly to a new perspective through clearer command of her own priorities, making new friends (heads up, audience members in the splatter zone) and cutting a rug along the way. I can't help but smile watching Suzie out on a date with someone else, a ruse to make her ex jealous, which translates like an episode of Love on the Spectrum. Icebreaker question: "What's your favourite colour?" Follow up: "If you were a mermaid, what colour would your tail be?"
Armit's physical comedy is a joy to watch, filling the Pip Theatre Main Stage with gawky grace and spontaneity. It is evident her Suzie character has even more potential to plumb and could easily carry a sequel or series. I enjoy the early 2000s montage tropes, and broader commentary on the progress women have made in the almost quarter century since then. Growing increasingly weary of misguided mentorship, Suzie learns to better discern between her actual goals and what she is only supposed to want - finding validation without a date. The tone of Suzie Sex Binge is light and the humour self-deprecating, following our protagonist's journey of self-discovery as she enters her fourth decade with at least slightly increased self-awareness. All aspects work wonderfully, as Armit's effortless connection endears the audience, investing us in Suzie's struggle to avoid ticking boxes off somebody else's list of goals she doesn't actually want herself, but never considered critically until now. An offbeat treat that is light yet satisfying, Suzie Sex Binge is highly recommended.
Melbourne audiences are in for an electrifying treat this season, with a bold, brazen and bespoke stage production of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest treading our shores at the glorious Athenaeum Theatre in Melbourne. This thrilling piece is as poignant as ever, gripping us with masterful performances by Australia's great acting pool of theatrical talent, led by iconic stars Jason Donovan and Nadine Garner.
Historically speaking, this mesmerising play is based on Ken Kesey's 1962 landmark novel, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. It was then adapted by Dale Wasserman and premiered on Broadway in 1963 (starring Kirk Douglas). Smelling a surefire hit, Douglas secured the stage and film rights, envisioning a theatrical debut that would lead to feature film success. In 1975, an iconic film was mounted: directed by Miloš Forman and starring Jack Nicholson as McMurphy. It went on to sweep the Oscars that year, winning for Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Director, and Best Adapted Screenplay. It is still regularly performed to packed houses all around the world, and to this day, still speaks to modern audiences everywhere.
Why is One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest such a modern classic? It touches on complex subject matters of the human condition, at a time when free-thinking was deemed irrational and downright dangerous. Where fear-mongering was de rigueur. Where mental illness was treated with such disdain, even in psychiatric systems who deemed to 'heal' their patients in a myriad of demeaning ways. Breaking a patient down to dust - physically, emotionally and spiritually.
Theatregoers, you are in for a voracious treat - One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest is not for the faint-hearted. It is a mélange of emotional rawness. A bit gritty in nature, and yet, hilarious moments too, creeping in at every turn. As an audience, we are witness to a beehive of beguiling humans trying to stay above water, locked inside the cold systematic environs of an Oregon psychiatric hospital. Governed by an equally cold Nurse Ratched, who rules with an iron fist. Where the patients have learned not to question anything, but to live by her rules.
Into this unbreathable setting we meet a new patient - rebellious soul Randle Patrick "Mac" McMurphy, exquisitely played by Jason Donovan. A gravely, in-your-face upstart. A man, who incidentally, is only there for an easy ride - faking insanity to avoid hard labour on a prison farm. Expecting to sit back and relax in the 'charming confines' of a mental health ward.
Yet McMurphy is irked by this environment, and by the robotic conformity around him. So, he refuses to submit and leads his own revolution-of-sorts. He finds himself a mission to help these wounded souls by inspiring them to go against the grain. To rediscover their own voices, wants and needs: by giving them back their dignity - while turning the ward upside down, despite the consequences.
Sneaky chaos ensues on every hilarious corner. There are erotic playing cards that provoke even the most upstanding of male hospital staff. There is a vote staged to watch the World Series. There is a basketball game with an ingenious human basket holder. And last but not least - McMurphy's ultimate pièce de résistance? Hosting a late-night sex-positive party to celebrate a fellow inmate's loss of virginity.
As to be expected, McMurphy's rebellious nature clashes with Nurse Ratched. What ensues is a battlefield of wills that is tantalising to watch. Akin to a psychological tête-à-tête - a wrestling match that slowly unveils the truly twisted underpinnings of a psychiatric system bound by unjust, immovable conduct.
Produced as a bespoke, all-Australian production by the innovative team at StoreyBoard Entertainment, the Stoddart Entertainment Group & Jason Donovan himself, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest's production team all bring their A-game in terms of stage mastery. The set design by Richard Roberts is on-the-money - pasty, cold and reeking of clinical; oozing a universal, stomach-churning, anxiety-inducing fear of hospital phobia. The costumes, designed by Ella Butler, all in uniformed shades of white, are cleverly designed in a more flexible fashion; so that they could be adapted through each character's journey, and moulded and adapted to the more erratic scenes that require more movement. The lighting design by Niklas Pajanti was illusionary and dreamily delivered, particularly in Chief Bromden's hallucinatory moments, bravely designing a sensitive, damaged and inflamed nervous system with originality and precision. The sound design by Marcello Lo Ricco was clear, alarming and bursting through the theatre with electrifying speed, with an aim to draw the audience in. And lastly, kudos to the original music composition by Kohan Van Sambeeck, who clung to a fortified mission - to unbalance the audience in deliberate disorientation - mixing different rhythms and synthesized sounds, including my most favourite of all - the traditional native scale, to set a spiritual tone against a hard-wired piece of theatre.
Every nuance, every silence, every scene, every output of characterisation from every single cast member in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest was amplified and breathlessly crafted under the masterful eyes of director Roger Hodgman. Darcey Eagle as Candy Starr, and Mia Dabkowski Chandler as both Nurse Flynn and Sandra, both depicted the sexy 60s siren archetypes to the hilt, breaking up the chilled ward environment with Ann-Margret, cougar-ish fun. Jack Scott and Deep Sroa, as Aide Williams and Aide Warren, were equally cunning and menacing; depicting the evil treatment that belied mental ward patients of that time - akin to schoolyard bullies. Harvey Almond as Dr. Spivey, displayed the see-sawing consciousness of a man caught in between his ethics and the rules of a broken institution, while Chris Connelly brought a great deal of comedy to his scenes, doubling up seamlessly as lobotomy patient Ruckley, as well as Aide Turkle, the ward's most questionable nighttime orderly.
A multifaceted ensemble bring next-level patient humour in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest with laughter at every delusional turn. Being the cherry on top was John Xintavelonis as endearing hallucinatory patient Martini, loosening the audience up with booming laughter. Another is Martin Blum's role as explosive-obsessed Scanlon, unknowingly to himself an unhinged bomb just waiting to go off. Another sympathetic nod goes to David James as Harding, the ward's leader and an intrinsically complicated man bound by his insecurities, expressed beautifully with exceptional well-roundedness.
A well-deserved accolade must go to Daniel R. Nixon, who plays Billy Bibbit, whose acting was simply supreme. Every time he spoke, the audience struggled with him. When his emotions pierced the stage, the audience fell silent and fought with him. His voice not only carried throughout the theatre like a crystal-clear bell, but urged us to run up and embrace Bibbit's wounded soul. For this reason alone, Nixon is the example of a brave new talent - who is a privilege to behold.
Gyton Grantley as exuberant, child-like Cheswick is a joy to watch. His wide-eyed, wondrous energy gives light to every scene, blending humour with bounce. He brought his character to life with a renewed physicality that simply shone, reminding Australian audiences why he is such a well-rounded star in any medium he appears in.
Jeremy Proulx, as half-Native American patient Chief Bromden in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest brings the deep-rooted, spiritual aspect to this piece - playing a hallucinatory narrator that introduces the audience to the depraved actions of a psychiatric ward. Central to his role, acting like a so-called deaf and dumb patient in order to be left alone, Chief Bromden is essentially the observer, an eye in the sky, a gentle giant seeking to escape the ward he is chained to and reclaim his Native American identity. Proulx plays the juxtaposition of his character's complexity with expertise; embodying a tearful lost boy one minute, and an imposing, lonesome figure the next, who finally grows in stature and flies away from his confines.
Nadine Garner, as Nurse Ratched, the foe-of-the-show, holds her role with clipped precision. Yet, instead of playing to strictness, Garner does the opposite, using a manipulative sense of playfulness, a cat-like meow - to tease the patients, as well as surprise us. Kudos to Garner for making this interesting acting choice, to play Nurse Ratched's feline power to trump her male patients, for her own personal benefit. Using allure as prey, for inevitable dominance: without a care in the world.
But Jason Donovan, as Randle P. McMurphy? Is simply born to play this role. From the moment Donovan arrives on stage, he is a force to be reckoned with. Donovan morphs into a performance of a lifetime with gusto, as a menacing hero, a man destined to be a seed of hope; creating a ripple effect by daring to stand up against a broken system of control and break free from society's rules. An iconic star, Donovan expertly knows who he is, and passionately expresses how the craft of acting is really done, by incorporating McMurphy into his whole entire being, mentally, physically and so severely. He gives a no-holds-barred approach towards making McMurphy in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest a legendary, unforgettable soul who is equally bad as he is good; teaching us that even within the chaos of man, there still lies a heart and spirit that can serve as a guiding force for others, beyond life's confines.
Why is One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest the perfect show for Melbourne audiences? It has a language and legacy beyond its time. It not only examines the frailties of the human condition; but examines institutional injustice itself - be it educational, religious or political. It is a story about human beings fighting for their own authenticity.
A challenge that any of us, at some point in our lives, can empathise with.
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest is exclusively showing at Melbourne's Athenaeum Theatre from now until December 20th 2026, for a strictly limited season, and is a classic masterpiece that is worth its weight in gold. It is raw, revolutionary, funny, and in many moments, truly confronting. If you are in the mood to see a groundbreaking work teamed with an unforgettable night of electrifying performances, then go see this once-in-a-lifetime, extraordinary piece of work. It's a night you won't forget.