Click if you liked this article
Agatha Christie is famously known as the Queen of Crime, and her mastery of the whodunit genre uses tight pacing, secluded settings, and an ensemble cast where everyone has a motive. Put director Susan Cridland O'toole in charge and it moves up several notches. Expect the Unexpected.
With a stella cast of quality actors who took the audience on a roller coaster game of guess who is telling the truth, we were teased and taunted by the ever-shifting perspective of who really did it.
Damien Campagnolo plays Michael Starkwedder, climbing in a window of a country manor to find a dead man in a wheelchair and a woman seemingly overcome by shock who confesses to the murder. With it being very evident he was shot, gory but not nightmarish luckily. But who is Michael, Damien plays his character as a stranger under the spell of the beautiful murderess - but watch for the subtle clues, he is a master of the poker face.
Viper Valu is dressed to kill and gives the audience the many sides of the newly widowed Laura Warwick, stringing the audience along with a mixed outburst of emotion and displays of a supposedly fragile physique.
All of the cast brought their characters to life and are to be commended on their stage skills. Crisp audible dialogue so the more mature of us didn't miss a word.



The household made up of Frances Price, Al Bromback, Petra Donnison, Andrew Paltridge, all deserve a mention for their characterisations and superb performances. From the energetic unstable Jan, played by Al who brought the childlike characteristics mixed with "Chucky" the killer to life to the more sedate matriarch figure of Mrs. Warwick played by Petra - all made the plot thicken, muddling the evidence until it was not clear who killed Richard Warwick.
Jeremy Wellwood played Inspector Thomas and whether intentional he brought rather a Pink Panther vibe to the role with his expressive eyebrows and facial expressions, giving the inspector a rather comedic persona. Aided by the clumsy Sergeant Cadwallader, played by Tom Cranitch, the audience were not left surprised they couldn't solve the crime as the clever script unraveled the clues.
Julian Farrar, played by Peter Norton, was very adept in playing the caring and then cold lover of (not going to spoil it, you have to see the play).
Set and costumes were excellent and look for a clue - a colour -again the director is making you use your powers of observation.
Nash has a dedicated team of volunteers who spend many hours creating effective sets - in this case it is the study of the victim.
Credits must also go to the production team and front of House, who deserve individual mention for the great effort and such a lovely welcoming theatre group.
Stage Manager -Al Bromback
Assist Stage Managers- Keeley Cogill, Hannah Devitt
Set Design- Phil Carney
Set Construction-Rob Crook (who played the victim very still), Phil Carney, Paul vanLieshout, Eddie Bruce, John stibbard
Lighting Design & Sound- Phil Carney (love the music choices Phil and Susan, very story appropriate)
Programmes- John Stibbard, Poster Design- Jason Nash, Banner-Gillian Nicholas
So, if you think you have read the story, do yourself a favour and see it brought to life.
You will well and truly get to make use of the grey matter.
The Unexpected Guest opened on 13 November and closes on the 5th of December at the New Farm Nash Theatre located in the Merthyr Road Uniting Church. Check out their website www.nashtheatre.com as they have also just released their 2027 season.
To book tickets to The Unexpected Guest, please visit https://nashtheatre.com/play-4-2026/.
