Andrea Gibbs’ Carol is pitched as following 60-year-old Carol as she fights to keep the Christmas spirit alive. While that’s certainly part of it, this five-actor show (with oh-so-many characters) delivers a timely and poignant social commentary on the reality faced by so many older women in Australia today. Even as Carol’s world unravels and is turned upside down, she continues to shoulder the mental load—something that resonated with many women in the audience.
The play’s themes of hope, resilience, and a woman’s ability to pivot shine through. Gibbs has been called a visionary playwright, and it’s clear this work was written by a woman. No matter what life throws at Carol, not once does she turn to a man and ask, “What’ll we do now?” She simply gets on with making the best of a bad lot.
The cast is exceptional. Sally-Anne Upton embodies the title role with heart and honesty, and the remaining ensemble (and backstage crew) switch roles with astonishing ease. At one point, Isaac Diamond morphs from therapist to son right before our eyes—I must have blinked, because the transformation was total but somehow I missed it actually happen.
The show itself is delightfully hard to categorise. Woven through its heart-wrenching, resilience-filled narrative is the most Aussie humour, including the antics of Santa—aka Sack Daddy—who opens the show with some enthusiastic audience participation (I’ve never been more relieved not to be in the first few rows). There’s plenty of laughter, and a healthy serve of colourful Aussie descriptors that rightly earn the production its explicit-language warning. Musical Director and Composer Jackson Harper Griggs sets the tone beautifully with original compositions; the music is a genuine highlight.
I can’t go past the set design. Bruce McKinven has outdone himself as set and costume designer, crafting a series of spectacular visuals. Walking into the Heath Ledger Theatre felt like stepping straight into the Australian landscape—each painted curtain backdrop richer and more evocative than the last.
Carol sits perfectly in that sweet spot between light and dark, humour and heartbreak. Congratulations to everyone involved.
Shows: For more information, visit the Black Swan website https://blackswantheatre.com.au/season-2025/carol. The season runs until 14 December and includes accessible sessions—audio description with tactile tour, Auslan-interpreted performances, and captioned sessions.
To book tickets to Carol, please visit https://blackswantheatre.com.au/season-2025/carol.
Photographer: Daniel J Grant