Chapter One of your life – if you are lucky, you may date, find your ‘person’, your one true love and live happily ever after. But what happens if that person isn’t there anymore? Do you find another True Love? Do you deserve a second chance at love? “chapter two”, written by Neil Simon and directed by Moja Band, is a fast-paced play exploring the human depth of emotional self-introspection.
Neil Simon is widely regarded as one of the most successful playwrights by his audience and peers. Over his career, he wrote more than 30 stage plays, many of which were adapted into major motion pictures – a rare achievement that highlights his influence on both theatre and film. Simon’s work earned him significant critical respect, reflected in his record for the highest combined number of Oscar and Tony nominations received by any writer in show business history. Having written comedies such as the well-known plays The Odd Couple and Biloxi Blues, I was looking forward to seeing the Hunter’s Hill Theatre’s production of “chapter two”.
When grieving widower George (Daniel Ferris) returns from an overseas trip that was meant to be healing following the loss of his beloved wife Barbara, his brother Leo (Simon Pearce) sets him up with Jennie (Laura Stead) who had gone through and come out the other side of a divorce. Though at first reluctant to return to dating, George relents and picks up the phone to call Jennie. What follows is a surprisingly strong connection between the two characters and they agree to meet that day in George’s apartment. A whirlwind romance blossoms during the first act leading to an unexpected (from the audience’s point of view) engagement after only knowing each other two weeks. Treated to the witty dialogue with the trademark one liner sharp comedic lines of Neil Simon, carried off with just the right amount of nuance and confidence by the two lead characters, I was hooked and asking myself, “where does it go from here?”.
Meanwhile, Jennie’s best friend Faye (Margareta Moir), a brassy actress unhappy in her loveless marriage, longs for attention and affection. Moir highlights Faye’s dramatic lunge into what she hopes will be a cloak and dagger affair with George’s brother Leo, a busy press agent. Pearce leans fully into the role of Leo, a smooth-talking philanderer (and proud of it!) and both he and Moir together deliver the lighter comedic scenes in contrast to some of the more complex themes his younger brother and Jennie are experiencing.
The second act sets out to explore some of these emotionally conflicting themes as George deals with his unresolved immense guilt about moving forward with his life with Jennie. I felt the weight of these heavy scenes as the actors encompass their characters.
Only two months ago, Ferris co-directed The Heartbreak Choir with Pymble Players, which I saw and loved. He quickly switched hats from director to actor onstage, with an outstanding performance playing all the complicated highs and lows of George. “chapter two” was semi-autobiographical, echoing similarities of Neil Simon’s life. Like his character, Simon was already a successful writer when his wife of twenty years passed away from cancer. He met and married his second wife just three months after she died. Drawing from his own guilt and subsequent pulling away from his second wife in the months shortly after their marriage, it is no wonder the dialogue felt so real and raw.
Jennie is left with the emotional fallout of George’s unhappiness during their honeymoon and on the return to their apartment. Stead’s performance led me to be cheering for her character to have a happy life as when we first met Jennie, she was bright, a real sweetheart and full of life. There were plants all around her apartment and from the first telephone conversation, Jennie’s optimism and sweetness was apparent. In the second act, Jennie stood up to George when he was saying some hurtful things to her, and the strength in these scenes showed us that she would fight for George because she loved him, and that she had the confidence to not be a replacement wife but be loved for who she is.
Stead delivers a commanding performance as Jennie, capturing her fierce independence, yet also her raw vulnerability. I had seen Stead some time ago performing the lead role in Hunters Hill Theatre’s “The Ballad of Maria Marten” and I remember that I was impressed by her acting then. It is to her credit that I didn’t recognise she was the same actress until I read her bio in the program, as that character was so different from the current character she was portraying; a testament to Stead’s acting.
The stage was divided into half, with each representing George and Jennie’s apartments. The lighting design by Antony Read worked well, using different types of light and strengths to highlight each. The sound design by Peter Tucker brought out the emotional moments in the play, with songs from the 1950’s lyrics delivering subtle messages to the audience. Well done to the lighting and sound operators Wayne Chee and Oliver Davies on the night I attended the play.
“chapter two” is a witty and emotionally raw masterpiece. Book your tickets to see Hunters Hill Theatre’s performance of this deeply moving play, which invites audiences to witness a story of self-reflection after tragedy and the courageous pursuit of true happiness, the second time around.
Season: 29 May 2026 – 21 June 2026
Running Time: Approx 2 hours with a 15 minute intermission
Club Ryde Ex. 728 Victoria Road, Ryde.
Tickets: www.huntershilltheatre.com.au
To book tickets to Chapter Two, please visit https://www.huntershilltheatre.com.au/.
