Paul Ellicott

“Close, But No Cigar” is a comedic, well-paced murder mystery, featuring a vibrant, young ensemble cast – a perfect elixir on a wet Autumn evening, with a gin and tonic from the well-stocked BackDock Arts bar. Originally adapted from a QUT Bachelor of Fine Arts graduating piece, “Close, but no Cigar” transforms the stage into a living noir film; The makeup, costumes and lighting achieve this in creative, unexpected ways, with evocative and elemental splashes of red contrasting the clever black and white aesthetic.

As noted in the program, playwright Samara Louise took a collaborative approach to developing this piece, asking the cast to create characters they were passionate about playing, developing those character’s backgrounds, subtext and context, and then building a storyline around them. Instead of a broad narrative, the play focuses largely on the character’s individual lives, which intersect at a Private Investigator’s office in the wake of the murder of Senator A. Williams. These characters are enveloped in their own lives, each with their own amusing idiosyncrasies and secrets.

Borrowing liberally from the archetypes of old detective films, the cast adopt New York accents to consistently good standard, their physical spacing and shapes mostly well-utilising the compact space they gather in. The cast of Cullyn Beckton as Dick Clark, Mitch Guyatt as Dr Graves, Caleb Hockings as Arthur Blackbird, Claudia Lyons as Odette Blair, and Lucy Wilding as Viviene Fareweather, all perform with aplomb. Their timing and interplay is slick, and all shine individually and together in a script that gives them each fairly equal attention and work to do. Director Cale Dennis weaves a golden thread through this production, cohesively combining the separate elements into an entertaining whole, elevated far above the sum of its parts.

For me, the script works best when played with a wink; Beckton and Hockings deliver this beautifully, showing dynamic movement, fine physical comedy, and the best-developed characterizations of the cast – receiving hearty laughter from a near-capacity audience. A couples of times I thought cast could have leaned more into the campy elements of the play; Wilding has beautifully graphic, dark eyes, and I’d like to see her use them more as story-telling weapons, especially in a role with scope to be extra. I wonder if physically repositioning the cast to deliver monologues more to the audience, rather than the upstage cast, may further aid audience connection and audibility. The addition of musical effects reminiscent of a pulpy, radio-play would also be a fun addition, which would further clarify the play’s identity.

That said, I can enthusiastically recommend “Close, But No Cigar” as a polished and playful production with further potential that left me with sore cheeks and a smile on my face.

To book tickets to “Close, But No Cigar”, please visit https://www.tickettailor.com/events/backdockarts/1528759?.

Spread the word on your favourite platform!